Yamaha YRS-24B
What We Like
- Baroque fingering matches most school methods
- Straight windway makes first notes easy
- One-piece body has no joint to crack
- Cheap enough to replace without wincing
Worth Noting
- No cleaning rod in the box
- Cotton bag is a sleeve, not a case
- Key
- C
- Weight
- 3.2 oz
- Included
- Cotton bag, fingering chart
- Fingering
- Baroque
Read the full review
The note from school usually names a recorder, and the Yamaha YRS-24B is the model that turns up on those lists most often. It's a soprano in C with baroque fingering — the system most classroom method books use — and a straight windway built to let a beginner make a clean sound without fighting the instrument. At 3.2 ounces and just under 13 inches, it's a size a third or fourth grader can hold up for a whole lesson.
We keep coming back to it because it removes the two things that make a first recorder miserable: a stuffy low register and a scramble to get any sound at all. The straight windway produces a soft, pure tone that doesn't punish normal breathing, and the notes come out clear enough that a beginner can hear whether they got it right. Put that at the bottom of this group's price range and it's the instrument we recommend before anyone has told us a thing about the child.
What the box doesn't include is cleaning gear. You get the recorder, a cotton bag and a fingering chart, and that's the lot. The body is a single piece, which we count in its favor — there's no joint to crack when a nine-year-old twists it the wrong way — but it does mean a cleaning rod belongs in the same order.
The bag is a sleeve rather than a case, so plan on a pencil box or something with a little padding. And put a name on it before the first lesson: this is the natural finish half the class will have, which is why some families go hunting for a colored instrument instead. The class will sound like a class either way.
Bottom line: Our pick for most kids: baroque fingering, an easy first octave, and a low price that makes a lost recorder a minor problem.