Melissa & Doug Best Friends Magnetic Dress-Up
What We Like
- Sliding lid keeps 78 pieces together
- Four figures let two kids play at once
- Widest wardrobe of the sets here
Worth Noting
- Many thumbnail-sized shoes and bows to track
- A few sleeves fit the dolls' arms loosely
- Figures
- 2 double-sided dolls, puppy and kitten
- Storage
- Wooden tray with sliding lid and handle
- Stated Age
- 3 to 6 years
- Magnetic Pieces
- 78 clothing and accessory pieces
Read the full review
An open wooden tray looks tidy in a product photo and behaves like an upturned drawer in real life: dozens of thumbnail-sized shoes, nothing holding them in. This is the set that fixes that at the source. The Best Friends tray slides shut, has a handle, and keeps the dolls, the clothes and the accessories in separate compartments, so the set leaves the shelf as one object and comes back as one object.
What's inside earns the extra spend over a single-doll set. Two double-sided dolls, a puppy, a kitten, four stands and 78 magnetic pieces mean two children can dress at the same time, which is the most useful thing about this box if you have a 3-year-old and a 6-year-old who both want the tiara. We think the pets are the smartest part of the design: they give a younger sibling something to hold that isn't the doll someone else is dressing.
The trade-off is piece count. Seventy-eight pieces means a lot of tiny shoes, bows and sunglasses, and while the compartments help, you'll be the one sorting them for the first year. It suits the stated 3-to-6 range; it is not the set to put in front of a 2-year-old, especially with a younger sibling in the room.
The Tiana set is the cheaper way to find out whether dress-up takes in your house, and the HABA tin is the better shape if the set will live in the car. Neither keeps 78 pieces together on a shelf, and that is the job this one does.
Bottom line: The set we recommend first: two double-sided dolls, two pets, 78 pieces, and a wooden case that actually closes, so the wardrobe survives past the first week.